Five-Star Expectations to One-Star Service: An Unforgettable Lesson in What NOT to Do! Raising the Barr Weekly Memo: Issue 553

Last weekend, Laurel and I decided to treat ourselves to a new restaurant, highly recommended by our foodie friend. Expectations were high, and our appetites even higher.

Once seated, our waitress, all smiles and pleasantries, took our orders, beginning with an exotic appetizer and a cocktail that seemed to have my name written on it. We launched into a conversation about the week gone by, fully expecting the drinks and starters to join the party soon.

Time passed, the minutes ticking away but undiscernible in the cacophony of chatty diners trying to converse over the too loud music drowning us out. We glanced at our watches, then at the still-empty tabletop, realizing that neither the appetizer nor the cocktail had arrived. Our waitress seemed caught in her own world, occasionally glancing our way with a vague promise in her eyes that the cocktail would materialize soon.

Despite the delay, we placed our entrée orders, still optimistic.

The clock ticked on. Forty-five minutes later, the appetizer finally arrived, its appearance no longer a cause for celebration. An hour later, the elusive cocktail made its grand entrance, only to find that my anticipation had withered, as the ice cubes had nearly entirely melted, and the diluted liquid sloshed over the top. One sip and I knew that the taste matched its unappealing appearance.

Upon receiving the bill, I found the forsaken cocktail still on the tab. The manager’s refusal to remove it from the bill led to a terse exchange, ultimately resulting in a call to my credit card company to dispute the charge. The ordeal left a bitter taste, unlike anything I’d experienced in my varied dining adventures.

Lessons Learned

• The Customer’s Perception is Reality: The manager’s dismissal of my complaint demonstrated a profound lack of empathy. Understanding and validating a customer’s feelings can foster loyalty, even when things go wrong.
• Apology as a Tool: A sincere apology and gesture of goodwill might have turned the evening around. Never underestimate the power of owning up to mistakes and making amends.
• Timeliness Matters: Delays in service can quickly dampen enthusiasm. Ensuring that the staff is well-coordinated and attentive can make or break the customer experience.
• Every Interaction Counts: From the waitress’s absentmindedness to the manager’s rudeness, each interaction shapes the overall experience. Training and empowering staff to be customer-centric can raise the bar for customer service.

In the end, our night out became a parable of how not to treat customers. Had the restaurant’s staff been trained in the fine art of customer care, not only would we have left satisfied, but we would likely have returned. Instead, we were left with a lesson in what to avoid, a cautionary tale we’ll be sure to share.

Get your copy of my latest new books available now on my Amazon’s author page.